The study of six graders' problem-solving performance, teachers' problem posing and teaching beliefs in different algebra problems

Chia Chatig Liu, Kai-Lin Yang, Hui Yu Hsu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper presents three investigations related to algebra problems; (1) Taiwanese sixth graders' problem-solving performance on story problems, word-equation problems, and equation problems; (2) Taiwanese mathematics teachers" posing sequences towards these problems and their hidden teaching beliefs; and (3) the relationship between student's performance and teachers' beliefs. These analyses revealed that sixth graders performed the best on equation problems and the worst on story problems. Further investigation indicated that although students performed better on equal ton problems, their algebraic thinking was still not well-developed. Second, about 80% mathematics teachers posed problems with the sequences of equation problems, word-equation problems, and story problems, respectively; they preferred the symbol-precedence view. They thought equation problems were easiest for students, and that word -equation problems should teach students how to directly find Hebraic solutions and the procedures of algebraic operations. They also agreed that algebraic equations were the most effective way to solve story problems and word-equation problems. The remaining teachers, who expressed a non-symbol-precedence view, believed that story problems should be taught first. Third, the comparisons showed the inconsistency between students "performance and teachers" predictions, especially those teachers with a non-symbol-precedence belief made the worst predictions.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)95-136
Number of pages42
JournalContemporary Educational Research Quarterly
Volume20
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2012 Jun 1

Fingerprint

Teaching
teacher
performance
student
mathematics
symbol

Keywords

  • Equation problems
  • Story problems
  • Symbol-precedence view
  • Teaching beliefs in algebra
  • Word-equation problems

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

The study of six graders' problem-solving performance, teachers' problem posing and teaching beliefs in different algebra problems. / Liu, Chia Chatig; Yang, Kai-Lin; Hsu, Hui Yu.

In: Contemporary Educational Research Quarterly, Vol. 20, No. 2, 01.06.2012, p. 95-136.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f0262dbbc492472bb1b080f4a2e9cfc8,
title = "The study of six graders' problem-solving performance, teachers' problem posing and teaching beliefs in different algebra problems",
abstract = "This paper presents three investigations related to algebra problems; (1) Taiwanese sixth graders' problem-solving performance on story problems, word-equation problems, and equation problems; (2) Taiwanese mathematics teachers{"} posing sequences towards these problems and their hidden teaching beliefs; and (3) the relationship between student's performance and teachers' beliefs. These analyses revealed that sixth graders performed the best on equation problems and the worst on story problems. Further investigation indicated that although students performed better on equal ton problems, their algebraic thinking was still not well-developed. Second, about 80{\%} mathematics teachers posed problems with the sequences of equation problems, word-equation problems, and story problems, respectively; they preferred the symbol-precedence view. They thought equation problems were easiest for students, and that word -equation problems should teach students how to directly find Hebraic solutions and the procedures of algebraic operations. They also agreed that algebraic equations were the most effective way to solve story problems and word-equation problems. The remaining teachers, who expressed a non-symbol-precedence view, believed that story problems should be taught first. Third, the comparisons showed the inconsistency between students {"}performance and teachers{"} predictions, especially those teachers with a non-symbol-precedence belief made the worst predictions.",
keywords = "Equation problems, Story problems, Symbol-precedence view, Teaching beliefs in algebra, Word-equation problems",
author = "Liu, {Chia Chatig} and Kai-Lin Yang and Hsu, {Hui Yu}",
year = "2012",
month = "6",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "95--136",
journal = "Contemporary Educational Research Quarterly",
issn = "1814-4810",
publisher = "國立台灣師範大學教育研究與評鑑中心",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The study of six graders' problem-solving performance, teachers' problem posing and teaching beliefs in different algebra problems

AU - Liu, Chia Chatig

AU - Yang, Kai-Lin

AU - Hsu, Hui Yu

PY - 2012/6/1

Y1 - 2012/6/1

N2 - This paper presents three investigations related to algebra problems; (1) Taiwanese sixth graders' problem-solving performance on story problems, word-equation problems, and equation problems; (2) Taiwanese mathematics teachers" posing sequences towards these problems and their hidden teaching beliefs; and (3) the relationship between student's performance and teachers' beliefs. These analyses revealed that sixth graders performed the best on equation problems and the worst on story problems. Further investigation indicated that although students performed better on equal ton problems, their algebraic thinking was still not well-developed. Second, about 80% mathematics teachers posed problems with the sequences of equation problems, word-equation problems, and story problems, respectively; they preferred the symbol-precedence view. They thought equation problems were easiest for students, and that word -equation problems should teach students how to directly find Hebraic solutions and the procedures of algebraic operations. They also agreed that algebraic equations were the most effective way to solve story problems and word-equation problems. The remaining teachers, who expressed a non-symbol-precedence view, believed that story problems should be taught first. Third, the comparisons showed the inconsistency between students "performance and teachers" predictions, especially those teachers with a non-symbol-precedence belief made the worst predictions.

AB - This paper presents three investigations related to algebra problems; (1) Taiwanese sixth graders' problem-solving performance on story problems, word-equation problems, and equation problems; (2) Taiwanese mathematics teachers" posing sequences towards these problems and their hidden teaching beliefs; and (3) the relationship between student's performance and teachers' beliefs. These analyses revealed that sixth graders performed the best on equation problems and the worst on story problems. Further investigation indicated that although students performed better on equal ton problems, their algebraic thinking was still not well-developed. Second, about 80% mathematics teachers posed problems with the sequences of equation problems, word-equation problems, and story problems, respectively; they preferred the symbol-precedence view. They thought equation problems were easiest for students, and that word -equation problems should teach students how to directly find Hebraic solutions and the procedures of algebraic operations. They also agreed that algebraic equations were the most effective way to solve story problems and word-equation problems. The remaining teachers, who expressed a non-symbol-precedence view, believed that story problems should be taught first. Third, the comparisons showed the inconsistency between students "performance and teachers" predictions, especially those teachers with a non-symbol-precedence belief made the worst predictions.

KW - Equation problems

KW - Story problems

KW - Symbol-precedence view

KW - Teaching beliefs in algebra

KW - Word-equation problems

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84865715392&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84865715392&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84865715392

VL - 20

SP - 95

EP - 136

JO - Contemporary Educational Research Quarterly

JF - Contemporary Educational Research Quarterly

SN - 1814-4810

IS - 2

ER -