Investigating the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking in the course of integrated activity in Taiwan

Yu-Lin Chang, Bei Di Li, Hsueh-Chih Chen, Fa Chung Chiu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The relationship lying between critical thinking and creative thinking is opposite or complementary, results of previous relevant researches have not yet concluded. However, most of researches put the effort to compare the respective effect of the thinking methods, either the teaching of creative thinking or that of critical thinking. Less of them showed the interest to investigate the combined effect of these two thinking skills teaching, especially its synergy. Therefore, present study aimed to discuss the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking, and investigated the joined effect of these two methods of thinking in the courses of ‘Integrated Activity courses’. Not only the separate influence but also the synergy would be our interests. Moreover, the outcome would also be compared with the learning result of single creative thinking skill teaching. Participants were 147 male students and 118 female students of ninth grade from 8 intact classes in a public middle school in Taiwan, the number of total participants were 265. Experimental design was ‘nonequivalent control group pretest/post-test quasi-experimental design’. Participants were assigned into three groups, three intact classes for creative thinking teaching group (EG1), three intact classes for ‘critical thinking and creative thinking combined teaching group (EG2)’ and two intact classes for regular teaching method group (watching video, control group). All participants took the assessment ‘The New Creative-Thinking Testing’ and ‘The Critical-Thinking Testing, Level 1’ after receiving the courses as post-test. Data were analysed statistically by one-way ANCOVA. The results showed that: Regards to the performance in Integrated Activity courses, no significant difference was found among students in EG1 and those in EG2. However, the students in both experimental groups got higher scores than those in control group did. As for the ability of critical thinking, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 and CG did, but no difference was found among the students in EG1 and those in CG. In respect of originality, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 did, the influence of critical thinking was significant.

Theoretical and possible applications of the results were also discussed. Present study not only manifests the correlation between creative thinking and critical thinking, but also provides the empirical data for synergy in actual pedagogical situations.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)341-360
Number of pages20
JournalEducational Psychology
Volume35
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015 Apr 3

Fingerprint

Creativity
synergy
Taiwan
Teaching
Students
Group
Control Groups
Thinking
Research Design
student
Aptitude
Research
Learning

Keywords

  • Integrated Activity courses
  • creative thinking
  • critical thinking
  • teaching for creative thinking
  • teaching for critical thinking

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
  • Education
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

Investigating the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking in the course of integrated activity in Taiwan. / Chang, Yu-Lin; Li, Bei Di; Chen, Hsueh-Chih; Chiu, Fa Chung.

In: Educational Psychology, Vol. 35, No. 3, 03.04.2015, p. 341-360.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{bd349f7c6a6d4c83ad705f591e94a796,
title = "Investigating the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking in the course of integrated activity in Taiwan",
abstract = "The relationship lying between critical thinking and creative thinking is opposite or complementary, results of previous relevant researches have not yet concluded. However, most of researches put the effort to compare the respective effect of the thinking methods, either the teaching of creative thinking or that of critical thinking. Less of them showed the interest to investigate the combined effect of these two thinking skills teaching, especially its synergy. Therefore, present study aimed to discuss the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking, and investigated the joined effect of these two methods of thinking in the courses of ‘Integrated Activity courses’. Not only the separate influence but also the synergy would be our interests. Moreover, the outcome would also be compared with the learning result of single creative thinking skill teaching. Participants were 147 male students and 118 female students of ninth grade from 8 intact classes in a public middle school in Taiwan, the number of total participants were 265. Experimental design was ‘nonequivalent control group pretest/post-test quasi-experimental design’. Participants were assigned into three groups, three intact classes for creative thinking teaching group (EG1), three intact classes for ‘critical thinking and creative thinking combined teaching group (EG2)’ and two intact classes for regular teaching method group (watching video, control group). All participants took the assessment ‘The New Creative-Thinking Testing’ and ‘The Critical-Thinking Testing, Level 1’ after receiving the courses as post-test. Data were analysed statistically by one-way ANCOVA. The results showed that: Regards to the performance in Integrated Activity courses, no significant difference was found among students in EG1 and those in EG2. However, the students in both experimental groups got higher scores than those in control group did. As for the ability of critical thinking, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 and CG did, but no difference was found among the students in EG1 and those in CG. In respect of originality, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 did, the influence of critical thinking was significant.Theoretical and possible applications of the results were also discussed. Present study not only manifests the correlation between creative thinking and critical thinking, but also provides the empirical data for synergy in actual pedagogical situations.",
keywords = "Integrated Activity courses, creative thinking, critical thinking, teaching for creative thinking, teaching for critical thinking",
author = "Yu-Lin Chang and Li, {Bei Di} and Hsueh-Chih Chen and Chiu, {Fa Chung}",
year = "2015",
month = "4",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1080/01443410.2014.920079",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "341--360",
journal = "Educational Psychology",
issn = "0144-3410",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Investigating the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking in the course of integrated activity in Taiwan

AU - Chang, Yu-Lin

AU - Li, Bei Di

AU - Chen, Hsueh-Chih

AU - Chiu, Fa Chung

PY - 2015/4/3

Y1 - 2015/4/3

N2 - The relationship lying between critical thinking and creative thinking is opposite or complementary, results of previous relevant researches have not yet concluded. However, most of researches put the effort to compare the respective effect of the thinking methods, either the teaching of creative thinking or that of critical thinking. Less of them showed the interest to investigate the combined effect of these two thinking skills teaching, especially its synergy. Therefore, present study aimed to discuss the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking, and investigated the joined effect of these two methods of thinking in the courses of ‘Integrated Activity courses’. Not only the separate influence but also the synergy would be our interests. Moreover, the outcome would also be compared with the learning result of single creative thinking skill teaching. Participants were 147 male students and 118 female students of ninth grade from 8 intact classes in a public middle school in Taiwan, the number of total participants were 265. Experimental design was ‘nonequivalent control group pretest/post-test quasi-experimental design’. Participants were assigned into three groups, three intact classes for creative thinking teaching group (EG1), three intact classes for ‘critical thinking and creative thinking combined teaching group (EG2)’ and two intact classes for regular teaching method group (watching video, control group). All participants took the assessment ‘The New Creative-Thinking Testing’ and ‘The Critical-Thinking Testing, Level 1’ after receiving the courses as post-test. Data were analysed statistically by one-way ANCOVA. The results showed that: Regards to the performance in Integrated Activity courses, no significant difference was found among students in EG1 and those in EG2. However, the students in both experimental groups got higher scores than those in control group did. As for the ability of critical thinking, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 and CG did, but no difference was found among the students in EG1 and those in CG. In respect of originality, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 did, the influence of critical thinking was significant.Theoretical and possible applications of the results were also discussed. Present study not only manifests the correlation between creative thinking and critical thinking, but also provides the empirical data for synergy in actual pedagogical situations.

AB - The relationship lying between critical thinking and creative thinking is opposite or complementary, results of previous relevant researches have not yet concluded. However, most of researches put the effort to compare the respective effect of the thinking methods, either the teaching of creative thinking or that of critical thinking. Less of them showed the interest to investigate the combined effect of these two thinking skills teaching, especially its synergy. Therefore, present study aimed to discuss the synergy of critical thinking and creative thinking, and investigated the joined effect of these two methods of thinking in the courses of ‘Integrated Activity courses’. Not only the separate influence but also the synergy would be our interests. Moreover, the outcome would also be compared with the learning result of single creative thinking skill teaching. Participants were 147 male students and 118 female students of ninth grade from 8 intact classes in a public middle school in Taiwan, the number of total participants were 265. Experimental design was ‘nonequivalent control group pretest/post-test quasi-experimental design’. Participants were assigned into three groups, three intact classes for creative thinking teaching group (EG1), three intact classes for ‘critical thinking and creative thinking combined teaching group (EG2)’ and two intact classes for regular teaching method group (watching video, control group). All participants took the assessment ‘The New Creative-Thinking Testing’ and ‘The Critical-Thinking Testing, Level 1’ after receiving the courses as post-test. Data were analysed statistically by one-way ANCOVA. The results showed that: Regards to the performance in Integrated Activity courses, no significant difference was found among students in EG1 and those in EG2. However, the students in both experimental groups got higher scores than those in control group did. As for the ability of critical thinking, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 and CG did, but no difference was found among the students in EG1 and those in CG. In respect of originality, students in EG2 got higher score than those in EG1 did, the influence of critical thinking was significant.Theoretical and possible applications of the results were also discussed. Present study not only manifests the correlation between creative thinking and critical thinking, but also provides the empirical data for synergy in actual pedagogical situations.

KW - Integrated Activity courses

KW - creative thinking

KW - critical thinking

KW - teaching for creative thinking

KW - teaching for critical thinking

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84926523815&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84926523815&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/01443410.2014.920079

DO - 10.1080/01443410.2014.920079

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 341

EP - 360

JO - Educational Psychology

JF - Educational Psychology

SN - 0144-3410

IS - 3

ER -