Fourth Graders' Cognitive Processes and Learning Strategies for Reading Illustrated Biology Texts: Eye Movement Measurements

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Previous research suggests that multiple representations can improve science reading comprehension. This facilitation effect is premised on the observation that readers can efficiently integrate information in text and diagram formats; however, this effect in young readers is still contested. Using eye-tracking technology and sequential analysis, this study investigated students reading strategies and comprehension of illustrated biology texts in relation to adult readers performance. The target population was fourth-grade students with high reading ability, and the control group was university students. All participants read a biology article from an elementary school science textbook containing two illustrations, one representational and one decorative. After the reading task, participants answered questions on recognition, textual, and illustration items. Unsurprisingly, the university students outperformed the younger students on all tests; however, more interestingly, eye movement patterns differed across the two groups. The adult readers demonstrated bidirectional reading pathways for both text and illustrations, whereas the fourth graders eye fixations only went back and forth within paragraphs in the text and between the illustrations, but made fewer references to both text and illustration. This suggests that regardless of their high reading ability, fourth-grade students visual literacy is not mature enough to perceive connections between corresponding features of different representations crucial to reading comprehension. Despite differences in cognitive processes between adult readers and young readers, high-ability young readers still have certain capabilities in reading comprehension. The results of sequential analysis showed that they looked back to previous paragraphs frequently, indicating that they were monitoring their comprehension.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)93-109
Number of pages17
JournalReading Research Quarterly
Volume51
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016 Jan 1

Fingerprint

Eye Movement Measurements
learning strategy
biology
Reading
Learning
Students
comprehension
Aptitude
student
ability
Textbooks
university
Health Services Needs and Demand
Eye Movements
science
textbook
elementary school
Young Adult
Group
literacy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

@article{3d55af1e27e14786b57ac24af458f2ef,
title = "Fourth Graders' Cognitive Processes and Learning Strategies for Reading Illustrated Biology Texts: Eye Movement Measurements",
abstract = "Previous research suggests that multiple representations can improve science reading comprehension. This facilitation effect is premised on the observation that readers can efficiently integrate information in text and diagram formats; however, this effect in young readers is still contested. Using eye-tracking technology and sequential analysis, this study investigated students reading strategies and comprehension of illustrated biology texts in relation to adult readers performance. The target population was fourth-grade students with high reading ability, and the control group was university students. All participants read a biology article from an elementary school science textbook containing two illustrations, one representational and one decorative. After the reading task, participants answered questions on recognition, textual, and illustration items. Unsurprisingly, the university students outperformed the younger students on all tests; however, more interestingly, eye movement patterns differed across the two groups. The adult readers demonstrated bidirectional reading pathways for both text and illustrations, whereas the fourth graders eye fixations only went back and forth within paragraphs in the text and between the illustrations, but made fewer references to both text and illustration. This suggests that regardless of their high reading ability, fourth-grade students visual literacy is not mature enough to perceive connections between corresponding features of different representations crucial to reading comprehension. Despite differences in cognitive processes between adult readers and young readers, high-ability young readers still have certain capabilities in reading comprehension. The results of sequential analysis showed that they looked back to previous paragraphs frequently, indicating that they were monitoring their comprehension.",
author = "Jian, {Yu Cin}",
year = "2016",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/rrq.125",
language = "English",
volume = "51",
pages = "93--109",
journal = "Reading Research Quarterly",
issn = "0034-0553",
publisher = "International Reading Association",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Fourth Graders' Cognitive Processes and Learning Strategies for Reading Illustrated Biology Texts

T2 - Eye Movement Measurements

AU - Jian, Yu Cin

PY - 2016/1/1

Y1 - 2016/1/1

N2 - Previous research suggests that multiple representations can improve science reading comprehension. This facilitation effect is premised on the observation that readers can efficiently integrate information in text and diagram formats; however, this effect in young readers is still contested. Using eye-tracking technology and sequential analysis, this study investigated students reading strategies and comprehension of illustrated biology texts in relation to adult readers performance. The target population was fourth-grade students with high reading ability, and the control group was university students. All participants read a biology article from an elementary school science textbook containing two illustrations, one representational and one decorative. After the reading task, participants answered questions on recognition, textual, and illustration items. Unsurprisingly, the university students outperformed the younger students on all tests; however, more interestingly, eye movement patterns differed across the two groups. The adult readers demonstrated bidirectional reading pathways for both text and illustrations, whereas the fourth graders eye fixations only went back and forth within paragraphs in the text and between the illustrations, but made fewer references to both text and illustration. This suggests that regardless of their high reading ability, fourth-grade students visual literacy is not mature enough to perceive connections between corresponding features of different representations crucial to reading comprehension. Despite differences in cognitive processes between adult readers and young readers, high-ability young readers still have certain capabilities in reading comprehension. The results of sequential analysis showed that they looked back to previous paragraphs frequently, indicating that they were monitoring their comprehension.

AB - Previous research suggests that multiple representations can improve science reading comprehension. This facilitation effect is premised on the observation that readers can efficiently integrate information in text and diagram formats; however, this effect in young readers is still contested. Using eye-tracking technology and sequential analysis, this study investigated students reading strategies and comprehension of illustrated biology texts in relation to adult readers performance. The target population was fourth-grade students with high reading ability, and the control group was university students. All participants read a biology article from an elementary school science textbook containing two illustrations, one representational and one decorative. After the reading task, participants answered questions on recognition, textual, and illustration items. Unsurprisingly, the university students outperformed the younger students on all tests; however, more interestingly, eye movement patterns differed across the two groups. The adult readers demonstrated bidirectional reading pathways for both text and illustrations, whereas the fourth graders eye fixations only went back and forth within paragraphs in the text and between the illustrations, but made fewer references to both text and illustration. This suggests that regardless of their high reading ability, fourth-grade students visual literacy is not mature enough to perceive connections between corresponding features of different representations crucial to reading comprehension. Despite differences in cognitive processes between adult readers and young readers, high-ability young readers still have certain capabilities in reading comprehension. The results of sequential analysis showed that they looked back to previous paragraphs frequently, indicating that they were monitoring their comprehension.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84955666148&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84955666148&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/rrq.125

DO - 10.1002/rrq.125

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84955666148

VL - 51

SP - 93

EP - 109

JO - Reading Research Quarterly

JF - Reading Research Quarterly

SN - 0034-0553

IS - 1

ER -