Application of DNA barcodes for testing hypotheses on the role of trait conservatism and adaptive plasticity in Acer L. section Palmata Pax (Sapindaceae)

Jian Gao, Pei-Chun Liao, Wan Heng Meng, Fang K. Du, Jun Qing Li

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Horticultural breeding mediates the selection of traits of interest, providing an opportunity for tracking phylogenetic potential of the trait shift. Here, we used Acer L. Sect. Palmata Pax and A. palmatum Thunb. cultivars as models to test phylogenetic signals of taxonomically relevant traits. Common chloroplast DNA barcoding markers facilitated the evaluation of genetic distance and phylogenetic relationships between these maple species. The determined short genetic distances resulted in unresolved relationships between A. palmatum cultivars and other Acer Sect. Palmata species after non-metric multidimensional scaling analysis, but was improved by discriminate analysis of principal components. However, genetic relationships among cultivars were clustered and admixed, indicating the same maternal source species for horticultural breeding. Phylogenetic reconstruction revealed an early Miocene origin for Acer Sect. Palmata. Cultivars and varieties of A. palmatum coalesced earlier than expected, indicating that the chloroplast markers cannot reflect the horticultural and breeding history of maples. Similar macroevolutionary rates of the infraspecies of A. palmatum with the species of Acer Sect. Palmata imply that the domestication and breeding process did not alter the speciation rate of this group. Nonsignificant phylogenetic signals for all the examined traits of Acer Sect. Palmata suggested that such species diversification could be explained by adaptive plasticity to paleoclimatic change. However, strong phylogenetic signals for leaf traits of infraspecies of A. palmatum suggested a phylogenetic-related trait shift during initial species divergence. Because the breeding process simulates divergent selection, we infer that genetic-based trait conservatism ensured a stable genetic basis for trait shift during initial species divergence.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)993-1005
Number of pages13
JournalRevista Brasileira de Botanica
Volume40
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017 Dec 1

Fingerprint

Sapindaceae
DNA barcoding
Acer
phylogeny
Acer palmatum
breeding
testing
cultivars
genetic distance
domestication
chloroplast DNA
genetic relationships
principal component analysis
chloroplasts

Keywords

  • Horticulture
  • Macroevolutionary rate
  • Phylogenetic signal

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Plant Science

Cite this

Application of DNA barcodes for testing hypotheses on the role of trait conservatism and adaptive plasticity in Acer L. section Palmata Pax (Sapindaceae). / Gao, Jian; Liao, Pei-Chun; Meng, Wan Heng; Du, Fang K.; Li, Jun Qing.

In: Revista Brasileira de Botanica, Vol. 40, No. 4, 01.12.2017, p. 993-1005.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{23c6b2dcb2664903bd9dcf49c61150be,
title = "Application of DNA barcodes for testing hypotheses on the role of trait conservatism and adaptive plasticity in Acer L. section Palmata Pax (Sapindaceae)",
abstract = "Horticultural breeding mediates the selection of traits of interest, providing an opportunity for tracking phylogenetic potential of the trait shift. Here, we used Acer L. Sect. Palmata Pax and A. palmatum Thunb. cultivars as models to test phylogenetic signals of taxonomically relevant traits. Common chloroplast DNA barcoding markers facilitated the evaluation of genetic distance and phylogenetic relationships between these maple species. The determined short genetic distances resulted in unresolved relationships between A. palmatum cultivars and other Acer Sect. Palmata species after non-metric multidimensional scaling analysis, but was improved by discriminate analysis of principal components. However, genetic relationships among cultivars were clustered and admixed, indicating the same maternal source species for horticultural breeding. Phylogenetic reconstruction revealed an early Miocene origin for Acer Sect. Palmata. Cultivars and varieties of A. palmatum coalesced earlier than expected, indicating that the chloroplast markers cannot reflect the horticultural and breeding history of maples. Similar macroevolutionary rates of the infraspecies of A. palmatum with the species of Acer Sect. Palmata imply that the domestication and breeding process did not alter the speciation rate of this group. Nonsignificant phylogenetic signals for all the examined traits of Acer Sect. Palmata suggested that such species diversification could be explained by adaptive plasticity to paleoclimatic change. However, strong phylogenetic signals for leaf traits of infraspecies of A. palmatum suggested a phylogenetic-related trait shift during initial species divergence. Because the breeding process simulates divergent selection, we infer that genetic-based trait conservatism ensured a stable genetic basis for trait shift during initial species divergence.",
keywords = "Horticulture, Macroevolutionary rate, Phylogenetic signal",
author = "Jian Gao and Pei-Chun Liao and Meng, {Wan Heng} and Du, {Fang K.} and Li, {Jun Qing}",
year = "2017",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s40415-017-0404-1",
language = "English",
volume = "40",
pages = "993--1005",
journal = "Revista Brasileira de Botanica",
issn = "0100-8404",
publisher = "Sociedade Botanica de Sao Paulo",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Application of DNA barcodes for testing hypotheses on the role of trait conservatism and adaptive plasticity in Acer L. section Palmata Pax (Sapindaceae)

AU - Gao, Jian

AU - Liao, Pei-Chun

AU - Meng, Wan Heng

AU - Du, Fang K.

AU - Li, Jun Qing

PY - 2017/12/1

Y1 - 2017/12/1

N2 - Horticultural breeding mediates the selection of traits of interest, providing an opportunity for tracking phylogenetic potential of the trait shift. Here, we used Acer L. Sect. Palmata Pax and A. palmatum Thunb. cultivars as models to test phylogenetic signals of taxonomically relevant traits. Common chloroplast DNA barcoding markers facilitated the evaluation of genetic distance and phylogenetic relationships between these maple species. The determined short genetic distances resulted in unresolved relationships between A. palmatum cultivars and other Acer Sect. Palmata species after non-metric multidimensional scaling analysis, but was improved by discriminate analysis of principal components. However, genetic relationships among cultivars were clustered and admixed, indicating the same maternal source species for horticultural breeding. Phylogenetic reconstruction revealed an early Miocene origin for Acer Sect. Palmata. Cultivars and varieties of A. palmatum coalesced earlier than expected, indicating that the chloroplast markers cannot reflect the horticultural and breeding history of maples. Similar macroevolutionary rates of the infraspecies of A. palmatum with the species of Acer Sect. Palmata imply that the domestication and breeding process did not alter the speciation rate of this group. Nonsignificant phylogenetic signals for all the examined traits of Acer Sect. Palmata suggested that such species diversification could be explained by adaptive plasticity to paleoclimatic change. However, strong phylogenetic signals for leaf traits of infraspecies of A. palmatum suggested a phylogenetic-related trait shift during initial species divergence. Because the breeding process simulates divergent selection, we infer that genetic-based trait conservatism ensured a stable genetic basis for trait shift during initial species divergence.

AB - Horticultural breeding mediates the selection of traits of interest, providing an opportunity for tracking phylogenetic potential of the trait shift. Here, we used Acer L. Sect. Palmata Pax and A. palmatum Thunb. cultivars as models to test phylogenetic signals of taxonomically relevant traits. Common chloroplast DNA barcoding markers facilitated the evaluation of genetic distance and phylogenetic relationships between these maple species. The determined short genetic distances resulted in unresolved relationships between A. palmatum cultivars and other Acer Sect. Palmata species after non-metric multidimensional scaling analysis, but was improved by discriminate analysis of principal components. However, genetic relationships among cultivars were clustered and admixed, indicating the same maternal source species for horticultural breeding. Phylogenetic reconstruction revealed an early Miocene origin for Acer Sect. Palmata. Cultivars and varieties of A. palmatum coalesced earlier than expected, indicating that the chloroplast markers cannot reflect the horticultural and breeding history of maples. Similar macroevolutionary rates of the infraspecies of A. palmatum with the species of Acer Sect. Palmata imply that the domestication and breeding process did not alter the speciation rate of this group. Nonsignificant phylogenetic signals for all the examined traits of Acer Sect. Palmata suggested that such species diversification could be explained by adaptive plasticity to paleoclimatic change. However, strong phylogenetic signals for leaf traits of infraspecies of A. palmatum suggested a phylogenetic-related trait shift during initial species divergence. Because the breeding process simulates divergent selection, we infer that genetic-based trait conservatism ensured a stable genetic basis for trait shift during initial species divergence.

KW - Horticulture

KW - Macroevolutionary rate

KW - Phylogenetic signal

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85037039567&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85037039567&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s40415-017-0404-1

DO - 10.1007/s40415-017-0404-1

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85037039567

VL - 40

SP - 993

EP - 1005

JO - Revista Brasileira de Botanica

JF - Revista Brasileira de Botanica

SN - 0100-8404

IS - 4

ER -